
From the Case Files of an Interstellar Field Operative
It had been raining for three days. Not particularly hard. Just relentlessly. Like an insurance salesman who knows you're home.
I sat in a rundown apartment in northern Germany, drinking whiskey that tasted like disinfectant and contemplating human civilization through a 27-inch monitor.
On this planet, my name was Walter Krüger. I was 58 years old, officially divorced, occasionally employed as a freelance journalist, and the owner of an Opel Astra with a busted exhaust.
In reality, I was 413 years old, came from the Tau Ceti system, and worked for the Department of Precivilizational Development Observation.
My assignment was simple: Observe. Document. Do not interfere.
Agency regulations were perfectly clear.
Especially about that last part.
Over the past eleven years, I'd cursed those regulations approximately eight thousand times.
It was the end of the month. My report was due.
I poured another drink.
A podcast was playing on the monitor. Two men were discussing a young woman named Greta Thunberg, who, a few years earlier, had attempted to alert her species to an impending ecological catastrophe.
(1:05:20)
An ambitious undertaking.
Humanity had responded by debating her hairstyle, facial expressions, mental health, and eventually her political opinions.
The ecological issues had somehow gotten lost in the shuffle.
Now the woman had laughed. (Greta Thunberg mocks German climate protests)
That was the big news.
She'd learned that people in Germany were still holding climate demonstrations, and apparently couldn't stop laughing.
The two men on the screen thought this was hilarious.
They laughed, too.
And then they laughed about the fact that she was laughing.
I waited for one of them to ask why she'd been laughing in the first place.
Neither did.
Instead, they launched into a lengthy discussion about how the mainstream media would suppress the incident.
I opened a major German news website in another window.
There was an article about the incident.
I closed the window.
On the monitor, one of the men announced that climate change was over. It was no longer a viable business model.
The other agreed.
I paused the video.
Then I looked at my glass.
It was empty.
"At least you've got an explanation," I told it.

The trouble had started almost as soon as I arrived.
My first report to Headquarters had been titled:
"Initial Evidence of Intelligent Life on Sol III."
Three months later, I'd revised it.
"Initial Evidence Suggesting the Possibility of Intelligent Life on Sol III."
After a year, it had become:
"Complex Tool Use in a Species of Uncertain Overall Cognitive Development."
Headquarters had complained that my observations were unnecessarily pessimistic.
That was before I'd explained the human concept of planned obsolescence.
A species that deliberately used its limited resources to manufacture objects designed to break down as quickly as possible, so it could manufacture more objects, was something even our behavioral biologists had never encountered.
One suggested the humans might be performing some kind of religious ritual.
Another suspected a form of collective self-punishment.
The truth was worse.
They called it economic growth.
I resumed the video.
The two men had moved on to discussing people who had glued themselves to roads to protest the destruction of their own environmental life-support systems.
This was also considered hilarious.
Some of the activists were supposedly drowning in debt. Others had even ended up in prison. And now they had to watch Greta Thunberg herself laughing at climate demonstrations.
A particularly delicious thought, the men agreed.
I made a note.
Subject exhibits pronounced schadenfreude toward members of his own species who have unsuccessfully attempted to preserve its long-term conditions for survival.
That sounded pretty good.
But not quite good enough.
I deleted the sentence.
Schadenfreude wasn't the problem.
Schadenfreude was widespread throughout the known universe. Even on the highly advanced planet Beltrax VII, there was a popular entertainment program in which members of the ruling caste pushed one another into vats of acid.
Of course, the Beltraxians possessed twenty-three brains and could regenerate damaged tissue within hours.
Humans had only one.
And even that seemed to give them trouble from time to time.

I opened the scientific databases.
Atmospheric CO₂ concentration: rising.
Global average temperature: rising.
Species extinction: ongoing.
Land sealed beneath concrete and asphalt: increasing.
Plastic particles: now found practically everywhere, including inside the bodies of the people manufacturing them.
Then I opened the comments beneath the video.
One man explained that the whole thing had been invented to control the population.
Another demanded proof.
A third wrote that nobody was going to take away his car.
A fourth recalled a particularly cold summer during his childhood.
A fifth declared the entire affair a communist conspiracy.
I switched back to the scientific database.
The CO₂ concentration hadn't changed.
I tried the comments section of another news website.
Same result.
It was fascinating.
Humans appeared to have developed a unique understanding of physical laws.
They believed those laws could be influenced by expressing opinions about them.
During my career, I'd encountered civilizations that sacrificed children to their gods in the hope of bringing rain.
Humans had modernized the procedure.
They no longer sacrificed their children directly.
They sacrificed their children's future and called it freedom.

Around midnight, I started writing my report.
INTERSTELLAR OBSERVATION AUTHORITY
Division 17-C: Developing Species
Monthly Report No. 132
Observation Target: Sol III, locally designated "Earth"
Species: Homo sapiens
Reporting Officer: Agent 73-B/19
Subject: Collective Intellectual and Moral Condition, November 2026
I stared at the empty text field.
There was no adequate word for it in the human language.
"Stupidity" didn't quite cover it.
Neither did "insanity."
After all, humans weren't fundamentally stupid. They could build particle accelerators, cure diseases, determine the ages of distant stars, and develop machines capable of assisting them with complex problems.
Some were even fairly good at chess.
At the same time, they required warning labels on plastic bags instructing them not to pull the bags over their heads.
Perhaps, I thought, intelligence wasn't a collective characteristic of this species.
Perhaps it was merely an occasional individual abnormality.
I began typing.
The observed species continues to display a substantial discrepancy between technological capability and collective rational decision-making.
Of particular concern is its systematic confusion of social conflict with empirical fact.
During the current observation period, a public controversy was documented in which a formerly prominent environmental activist laughed at the continued use of certain protest methods.
Segments of the population interpreted this as evidence that the environmental problems underlying those protests did not exist.
The conclusion is logically invalid.

I stopped.
That was the trouble with Headquarters.
They expected scientific precision.
The disadvantage of scientific precision was that, when confronted with reality, it sometimes sounded like unintentional comedy.
I continued.
The subjects displayed no apparent inclination to verify the original claims against available observational data.
Instead, the interaction centered on the public humiliation of a symbolic adversary and speculation concerning the media's anticipated response.
Particularly noteworthy was the repeated prediction that mainstream media outlets would refuse to report the incident, despite the fact that such reporting already existed.
This contradiction did not result in any revision of the prediction.
The phenomenon appears to be widespread within the species.
I considered that last sentence.
Then I added:
It is apparently known as freedom of opinion.
At two in the morning, I went outside.
The rain had stopped. The air smelled of wet asphalt, diesel fumes, and the faint odor of decomposition drifting from a dumpster behind the supermarket.
Across the street stood an SUV.
An enormous thing. Two tons of steel, plastic, electronics, and painstakingly extracted natural resources, designed to conquer difficult terrain.
Its owner mainly used it to drive to the bakery.
The bakery was six hundred meters away.
I'd once asked the man why he needed such a vehicle.
"Safety," he'd said.
I'd pointed out that smaller vehicles were safer for other road users, and that his oversized machine contributed significantly to the very danger he was trying to protect himself against.
He'd looked at me as though I'd just tried to rape his mother.
He hadn't said hello to me since.

It was one of those situations I'd once considered a misunderstanding.
I knew better now.
Back in the apartment, a message from Headquarters was waiting.
REQUEST FOR STATUS ASSESSMENT
Agent 73-B/19,
Your recent reports indicate growing skepticism regarding the species' developmental prognosis.
We request an updated assessment of the probability that the observed species will establish a stable planetary civilization within the next 200 standard years.
Please pay particular attention to the fact that the species possesses considerable scientific and technological resources.
I read the message twice.
Then I replied:
The species also possesses considerable resources devoted to the manufacture of weapons.
It has developed technologies capable of destroying its entire civilization within a matter of hours.
At the same time, it is developing artificial intelligence systems whose capabilities may eventually surpass its own cognitive abilities.
The overwhelming majority of its economic activity is devoted to the production, distribution, and disposal of objects that are not necessary for sustaining life.
A substantial portion of the population considers restrictions on this process a more serious loss of freedom than the potential destruction of the ecological conditions required for its continuation.
The development of a stable planetary civilization is therefore technically possible.
Whether it is socially desirable remains unclear.
I sent the reply.
Five minutes later, another message arrived.
FOLLOW-UP QUESTION
Why would a species not wish to ensure its own long-term existence?
I got up, walked to the window, and looked outside.
Somewhere, a dog was barking.
A television was playing in one of the neighboring apartments.
A commercial promised a man that he could finally be happy if he bought a new car.
His current car was three years old.
I returned to my desk.
The species does wish to continue existing.
It simply doesn't want to pay for the conditions that make continued existence possible.
At two-thirty, I opened the podcast again.
The two men were still laughing.
Not literally, of course. It was a recording. But the distinction was beginning to seem increasingly philosophical.
I watched them.

Over the past eleven years, I'd observed many people like these. Some wore suits and sat in parliaments. Others wore lab coats and explained on television why everything wasn't nearly as bad as it looked. Still others wore nothing remarkable and posted their revelations in comment sections.
The underlying mechanisms were astonishingly similar.
Some didn't want to know anything.
Others wanted to be told what they were allowed to know.
And a third group was primarily concerned with ensuring that nobody could take anything away from them.
For a long time, I'd tried to determine which group was the most dangerous.
By now, I suspected it didn't matter.
It was like watching the crew of an airplane argue about whether the warning light was really red, while the passengers demanded that the seat belt signs be turned off because they'd paid for their tickets.
Meanwhile, the pilot was busy privatizing the in-flight catering service.
Shortly before sunrise, I finished the report.
Only the final recommendation remained.
Normally, that section contained things like:
Continued observation recommended.
Or:
Initial signs of positive developmental momentum.
Or, in the case of the inhabitants of Gamma Draconis IV:
Contact temporarily suspended, as the species has declared its own sun to be God and has shot down every space probe as an act of blasphemy.
I thought about it for a long time.
Then I wrote:
Final Assessment
The observed species possesses the scientific means to recognize its existential problems and, at least in part, the technological means to address them.
Implementation, however, is obstructed by competing status interests, short-term reward mechanisms, institutional inertia, and a pronounced tendency to identify with symbolic conflicts.
In the case examined, criticism of a method of protest was mistaken for refutation of the issue being protested.
Such a cognitive failure would not be unusual in a pretechnological species.
In a species that operates nuclear reactors, constructs interplanetary probes, and alters its own atmosphere on a planetary scale, it constitutes a matter of considerable security concern.
I recommend reconsidering the current classification of "Developing Civilization."
As an alternative designation, I propose:
"Technologically Advanced Transitional Phenomenon."
I signed it.
Then I leaned back and watched the first light of dawn.
The sky above the rooftops had turned that dirty shade of orange humans considered romantic and which, on my home planet, would have triggered an immediate evacuation.
I thought about the young woman who had laughed.
About the two men who had laughed at her laughter.
About the millions of viewers delighted that somebody, somewhere, had said something that could be interpreted as a defeat for the other side.
About all the people who stood on the sidelines and watched.
And about myself.
After all, I'd become one of them, at least in appearance.
Here I sat, drinking bad whiskey, writing reports, and waiting for something to happen.

The only difference was that I had an emergency evacuation transponder.
It was lying in my desk drawer.
A small black device with a single button.
Sometimes I took it out and looked at it.
Sometimes I wondered what it would be like to simply disappear.
But then I remembered the agency regulations.
Observe. Document. Do not interfere.
I reopened the final section of my report.
Under "Personal Remarks," I added one sentence.
I'm no longer sure whether I'm observing a civilization in the process of failing, or a civilization whose actual purpose I have yet to understand.
Then I submitted the report.
Outside, someone started his SUV.
The engine roared.
Six hundred meters to the bakery.
I poured myself the last of the whiskey.
On the monitor, the algorithm had already suggested the next video.
"THE TRUTH THEY DON'T WANT YOU TO KNOW!"
1.2 million views.
I clicked on it.
A job's a job.
Keine Kommentare:
Kommentar veröffentlichen
Hinweis: Nur ein Mitglied dieses Blogs kann Kommentare posten.